Skip to main content

Insight article

November 14, 2023

Expert witness in the Cayman Islands K-Electric dispute

Our Managing Partner Bilal Shaukat served as an expert witness on Pakistan law in the Cayman Islands Court for a case related to K-Electric, providing written opinion and testimony.

RIAA Barker Gillette Expert witness testimony given in K-Electric dispute

In October 2022, certain indirect shareholders of K-Electric Ltd, the vertically-integrated electricity provider for Karachi, filed proceedings in the Sindh High Court challenging a transaction in the Cayman Islands resulting in the change in ownership of another major indirect shareholder, the Infrastructure and Growth Capital Fund (IGCF).

The Sindh High Court granted an injunction restraining IGCF from implementing the transaction. The proceedings in the Sindh High Court sought to prevent the appointment of IGCF’s nominees to the board of K-Electric.

In response, IGCF filed anti-suit injunction proceedings before the Financial Services Division of the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands, seeking the discontinuation of proceedings before the Sindh High Court. The Cayman proceedings involved questions of Pakistan law concerning the jurisdiction of Courts and the enforceability of exclusive jurisdiction clauses.

IGCF engaged our Managing Partner, Bilal Shaukat, as a Pakistan law expert witness. He provided a written opinion on the legal questions and presented himself for cross-examination.

In his judgment, the presiding Honorable Justice Segal made several observations about our assistance, stating,

I found Mr Shaukat to be a reliable and helpful witness who set out his opinions, both in writing and orally during his cross-examination, clearly with supporting analysis and arguments. He dealt directly and candidly with points of difficulty and adopted a balanced and impartial approach… I found his analysis to be clear and cogent and supported by the applicable law and authorities.”

Honorable Justice Segal

Relying on our expert witness testimony, the Cayman Court allowed IGCF’s application and granted the anti-suit injunction.

Bilal Shaukat observed:

“Our engagement by IGCF and this outcome is a testament to RIAA Barker Gillette’s capabilities and experience in multi-jurisdictional disputes concerning Pakistan’s energy sector. We congratulate IGCF on this important victory in the Cayman proceedings.”

Bilal Shaukat, Managing Partner – Pakistan, RIAA Barker Gillette

Pakistan’s Managing Partner, Bilal Shaukat, led the team working on this matter with assistance from Pakistan Partner Shahbakht Pirzada.

For further information, contact our Managing Partner, Bilal Shaukat or read the press coverage.

This article is not legal advice; it provides information of general interest about current legal issues.


RIAA Barker Gillette is Pakistan’s premier law firm, with an on-the-ground presence in four major cities in Pakistan: Karachi, Islamabad, Lahore, and Peshawar, and affiliated offices in Dubai (DIFC) and London.

The firm practices in all areas of corporate, commercial and dispute resolution law. Leading international legal directories consistently recognize the firm as a top-tier law firm in Pakistan.

Lex Mundi Logo

RIAA Barker Gillette is the exclusive member firm in Pakistan for Lex Mundi, the world’s leading network of independent law firms with in-depth experience in over 125 countries worldwide.  

Stay in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in touch
Sending

News/Insight

  • Importance of a name – RIAA wins dismissal of PKR 425 million suit

    The concept of legal personality lies at the heart of the law. Legal persons are the subjects of legal relationships, which confer rights and impose obligations. Most obviously, the law recognizes individuals as natural perso


    Read more
  • RIAA Defends Leading Battery Manufacturer in Tax Fraud FIRs

    We are representing a leading automotive battery manufacturer in tax fraud FIRs filed by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). The automotive battery sector is one of the five industries Read more

  • Sindh High Court grants injunction in shipping shortage claim case

    The Sindh High Court recently granted an interim injunction restraining the civil court from passing judgment in suits alleging short landing of imported edible oil cargoes. The injunction, secured by RIAA Barker Gillette on


    Read more
  • RIAA challenges denial of concessional customs duty for pharma industry

    We represent a global consumer healthcare and pharmaceutical industry leader in a complex customs duty dispute before the Sindh High Court. The case challenges the denial of concessionary customs duty rates on materials requi


    Read more
  • Pakistan Public Private Partnership Laws 2025

    We authored the Read more

What clients say...

  • Chambers Asia Pacific 2022
    "RIAA are responsive, professional and polite in explaining their advice, well researched in their opinions, and reliable in their response time… they also share commercial and operational consequences of the options presented in their advice. We are very happy with their support…." - Chambers Asia Pacific 2022

  • The Legal 500 2022
    “RIAA has an excellent litigation practice that advises on the full range of contentious issues as well as international arbitrations. The practice regularly handles all forms of civil, commercial, corporate, regulatory and white-collar crime matters before all the courts in Pakistan. It has extensive experience in a diverse range of industry sectors …” – The Legal 500 2022

  • Chambers Asia Pacific 2022
    "We find them to be extremely professional and responsive. They are meticulous in raising all the right legal points but at the same time are very solution-oriented in helping to structure the transactions in the right way to fully protect our legal rights." – Chambers Asia Pacific 2022

  • The Legal 500 2022
    “The team has an excellent track record of working on some of the most significant projects in Pakistan throughout the years.” – The Legal 500 2022 

  • Legal 500 2021
    We have worked with RIAA Barker Gillette for many years on a number of matters, including regulatory issues, labor, general corporate, competition law, and tax matters…..We have found high-quality lawyers across disciplines, who are able to balance the requirement for technically sound advice while also being practical and solution-orientated - Legal 500 2021

Read more
Send this to a friend