Skip to main content

Insight article

April 16, 2020

Relying on legal advice can provide a defence

Taking legal advice and honestly relying on it can stand as a defence to claims where a defendant’s necessary belief must be demonstrated for the claim to be successful.

In the recent Court of Appeal case David Allen t/a David Allen Chartered Accountants v Dodd & Co Limited, Dodd & Co escaped liability for inducing a breach of contract because they had sought legal advice on their intentions before acting which provided them with a defence. They successfully demonstrated that they had honestly relied upon the legal advice they were given, even though that advice was incorrect.

Facts

Mr Pollock worked at David Allen Chartered Accountants (David Allen). His employment contract contained non-compete and non-solicitation clauses, commonly known as post-termination restrictions or restrictive covenants. Dodd & Co wished to employ Mr Pollock and were aware of his restrictive covenants. Before employing him, Dodd & Co sought legal advice on the enforceability of Mr Pollock’s restrictive covenants and were advised:

“…the restrictive covenant hasn’t got a lot going for it. You could, therefore, act and allow [Mr Pollock] to act on the basis that it isn’t enforceable and contact David Allen’s clients. This is almost certain to provoke a strong reaction. He will probably write to [Mr Pollock] setting out why he believes [Mr Pollock] is in breach…”

As a result of that advice, Dodd & Co employed Mr Pollock, as whilst not entirely without risk, it was more likely than not that the restrictive covenants were unenforceable. In fact, the court held that the covenants were enforceable, and by working for Dodd & Co, Mr Pollock was in breach. Nonetheless, the court rejected the claim against Dodd & Co, brought by David Allen, for inducing the breach by Mr Pollock on the basis that they had relied honestly on the legal advice they had obtained.

The Court of Appeal’s decision

The decision was subject to appeal, and the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court’s decision. It found that Dodd & Co were not ignorant of Mr Pollock’s contractual obligations and had gone to the trouble of obtaining legal advice before offering him employment. The fact that the legal advice turned out to be wrong was not enough for David Allen to be successful in his claim against Dodd & Co. During the appeal, David Allen argued that there should be liability whenever a defendant believes there is a risk that its conduct, in this case employing Mr Pollock, would cause a breach. The court rejected the argument:

“As everyone knows, lawyers rarely give unequivocal advice; and even if they do the client must appreciate that there is always a risk …that the advice will turn out to be wrong.”

Although this case focuses on restrictive covenants in an employment setting, it is important to remember that the tort of inducing a breach of contract applies to all manner of contracts, and it is best practice to seek legal advice early on. Where a party honestly relies on such advice, it may prove to be a defence to the tort of inducing a breach of contract.

The courts accept that a solicitor’s advice is rarely definitive and will inherently attach an element of risk. Generally, the party seeking that advice must weigh up any risks identified within the advice before acting upon it – even if, in some circumstances, it may still provide a suitable defence.

The message is clear; always consult a solicitor before acting!

Call Karen Cole today for advice and information.

Note: This is not legal advice; it provides information of general interest about current legal issues.

Stay in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in touch

By completing your details and submitting this form you confirm you are happy for us to send you marketing communications and that you agree to our Website Privacy Policy and Legal Notice and to us using Mailchimp to process your data.


Sending

News/Insight

  • Autumn Budget Statement 2024
    Key implications for employment law, property law, and estate planning


    Read more
  • Disclosure against warranties in UK corporate transactions
    In UK corporate transactions, disclosure of information is a vital strategy for sellers to shield themselves from warranty claims when selling their shares or business.


    Read more
  • How the Employment Rights Bill 2024 impacts employers and businesses
    The government’s new Employment Rights Bill outlines significant changes to employment laws, focusing on workers' rights and flexibility.


    Read more
  • Business First Magazine
    Autumn/Winter 2024 Edition


    Read more
  • Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): An Overview
    A Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs), also known as a Confidentiality Agreement, is a legally binding contract designed to protect confidential information. It is often used in employment or business settings. NDAs ensure that sensitive information rem


    Read more

What they say...

  • Man Kiu Wan, November 2024
    “Thank you Charlotte for your excellent and professional services.” Probate

  • Ms K, November 2024
    “I was recently made redundant, and my company had handled some of the process quite poorly. Patrick came recommended by a friend who had used him during her own redundancy, and I can now wholeheartedly recommend him myself. His initial consult

  • Sean Greathead, October 2024
    “Karen Cole has been superb in supporting us in dealing with some complex legal challenges. Her advice and guidance is timely, well communicated and provides direction on resolving the situations on hand. I would highly recommend Karen and the

  • Jonny Grossman, October 2024
    “Martin was everything I would expect a top solicitor to be. He was knowledgeable, responsive, supportive, calm, and overall an excellent professional to work with. I would use Martin and RIAA Barker Gillette again without hesitation. Sharon is

  • Carlo, September 2024
    “Very efficient. Maheen and Pippa were great, offered great advise and always available.” Family law and divorce

Read more
Send this to a friend