Skip to main content

News story

February 7, 2017

Courts hit high and hard with new health and safety fines

One year after the introduction of tough new health and safety sentencing guidelines, a series of high profile cases show that courts are not holding back when it comes to imposing the higher fines, which can be directly linked to a corporate defendant’s turnover.

Health and safety lawyer Vinay Verma looks at the impact a year on of the tough new health and safety sentencing guidelines,

In the latest case involving £1bn household retailer Wilko, an incident left an employee permanently paralysed after a roll cage containing 230kg of paint fell onto her as she manoeuvred it out of a lift. The company was charged with four offences under the Health and Safety at Work Act, and Wilko accepted their risk processes had failed, pleading guilty to the charges. The combination of a high turnover company, high culpability, and a serious level of harm to the employee resulted in a £2.2m fine.

Similarly, a fine of £5 million was imposed on Merlin Entertainments in September last year, following the major incident on the Smiler ride at their Alton Towers theme park in 2015. The incident left sixteen people injured, some with catastrophic, life-changing injuries, including two teenage girls who had to have leg amputations.

Vinay Verma, our resident Health and Safety lawyer, said:

“Such cases generally involve real human tragedy, as in these two examples, and the new tariffs are intended to recognise the seriousness of that, with fines related to turnover, although the courts have discretion to push fines up or down according to profitability. But the one thing that is clear from the sentencing guidelines is that any fine must be sufficiently substantial to have a real economic impact, to bring home the importance of health and safety.”

He added:

“It’s vital to have excellent health and safety systems and policies, and to keep them regularly reviewed and updated, with everyone – workers and management – keeping best practice at the forefront of their daily work.

As well as helping to avoid accidents in the first place, such processes will help to mitigate or support any defence against criminal liability or negligence.”

Call health and safety lawyer Vinay Verma today to find out more information.

Note: This is not legal advice; it provides information of general interest about current legal issues.

Stay in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in touch

By completing your details and submitting this form you confirm you are happy for us to send you marketing communications and that you agree to our Website Privacy Policy and Legal Notice and to us using Mailchimp to process your data.


Sending

News/Insight

  • New sexual harassment rules may signal changes to office parties or a decline altogether
    Tomorrow is expected to be one of the busiest nights for office Christmas parties this year. While these celebrations are a staple of the festive season, offering a chance for colleagues to unwind and bond, they also bring unique challenges for emplo


    Read more
  • Employers need to support couples during relationship breakups
    Family Christmases are often followed by the news of unhappy couples calling it quits in January, leading to so-called "Divorce Day", as family lawyers receive numerous enquiries when they reopen after the Christmas break.


    Read more
  • What are trustee responsibilities? A guide to key duties and best practices
    Trustees' responsibilities encompass a wide range of duties when overseeing a trust estate under their care.


    Read more
  • What is the Employment Rights Bill 2024?
    The Employment Rights Bill 2024 marks a pivotal moment in UK employment law, promising the most significant reforms in over three decades


    Read more
  • Autumn Budget Statement 2024
    Key implications for employment law, property law, and estate planning


    Read more

What they say...

  • Howard, December 2024
    “Outstanding service. The process from start to finish was run so smoothly. Very professional and everyone involved was a pleasure to deal with and helped with easy to understand guidance, especially during this difficult time of losing a close

  • Ms McVeigh, December 2024
    Advice on redundancy, exit negotiations and settlement “I would like to express my gratitude to RIAA Barker Gillette (UK) LLP and specifically, Patrick Simpson for handling my case with professionalism whilst being prompt and personable. The pr

  • Rob Henderson, December 2024
    “Thoroughly professional. Way to deal with and access.” Contract review

  • Ms Lind, December 2024
    “I would highly recommend Patrick! Patrick advised me when I was being made redundant, making sure I was aware of my rights and advocated for me in all communications with my company. He came across very professional, trustworthy and knowledgea

  • Pal Peshikaj, December 2024
    “Compare Ben Marks and Martin Alfreds with MJ and Pippen – the conveyancers dream team. Both Ben and Martin were amazing in assisting us with the completion of our first purchase. Martin was always accessible, understanding and prompt whe

Read more
Send this to a friend